Car Camping Tents (Kelty, Paha Que, Hilleberg)

A small tent really has no place at the common drive-up campsite. For car camping, you want a cavernous, feature-full, stand-up-and-stretch-out nylon lodge with pockets, vestibules and all the bells and whistles. Here’s my quick review on three such outsized tent models:

The Paha Que Promontory was the largest of the tents in this review. It’s made to sleep up to eight adults with 120 square feet of space inside. The ceiling has a peak height of 7 feet. There are three doors, two windows, and a removable divider sheet to let campers create a veritable nylon castle with two distinct rooms.

PahaQuƩ-PromontoryW.jpg

This is the kind of tent in which you can set up cots, chairs and a large table to play cribbage late into the night under the flickering light of a lantern. Or, a large family of six or even more can sleep comfortably under one roof. For storage, the company (www.pahaque.com) includes removable gear attics, which are swaths of nylon that connect up high by the ceiling for storing clothing or lightweight camp accessories.

Despite its impressive size, the Promontory has several faults. Its boxy shape, for example, is about as non-aerodynamic as a tent design can be. Wind hits the Promontory’s outside walls with a brute force that causes the nylon walls to arc inward and push against campers on the floor. The tent’s awning is poorly designed, as it sags in the middle if not staked out as tight as can be.

While weight is not a huge concern for car camping, the Promontory is ridiculously large when packed up, weighing 24 pounds and taking up about a quarter of the trunk space in my car. It retails for $419, which I felt was too high for a tent with more than one significant fault.

Kelty pitches its new Pagoda as a tent that brings backpacking technology to the campground. Indeed, this big dome tent looks like an enlarged version of many small, lightweight models made for long wilderness treks, but it includes luxuries like multiple interior mesh pockets for gear stowage, two doors, a window and air-flow vents to keep things cool inside.

Kelty-PagodaW.jpg

The six-person tent has a large vestibule with about 30 square feet of space. Inside, there is about 100 square feet of space, which is enough room to comfortably sleep four or cozily sleep six. Rolled up and packed in its duffle, the Kelty tent ($400, www.kelty.com) weighs about 20 pounds.

Hilleberg’s Stalon Combi tent has an interesting tunnel design, which sets up with three poles and several staked guy lines. While it is the smallest tent in the review, there is still about 50 square feet of space to fit four adults with their gear stashed away in the two zip-off vestibules.

Hilleberg-StalonCombi(tent)W.jpg

It is less than 4 feet tall, so you cannot stand up inside, but this lower profile, in addition to the curved, tunnel form factor, causes wind to flow over and around the Stalon Combi with little resistance.

Packed up, the tent weighs about 10 pounds, making it usable for canoe camping or on a backpacking trip where the tent’s contents are divvied up into the packs of several hikers.

The Stalon Combi is not a freestanding design, meaning multiple guy lines must be staked out to keep it upright. And all these thin guy lines on the tent have the potential to get quite tangled if you’re not careful when packing the tent away.

At $620, Hilleberg’s (www.hilleberg.com) Stalon Combi is quite pricey. But it’s a quality tent made to stand up to stiff weather while providing a roomy interior for weekend campers as well as trekkers or serious mountaineers using the tent at a high and gusty base camp.

Posted by Jason - 02/11/2009 10:57 AM

The Promontory has 120sq ft of space inside, not 100. And it is no longer made of nylon. We have since upgraded to a far better material: 150D poly. And despite the “boxy” appearance, it is super resistant to wind and if the walls were being blown in and pushing against campers on the floor there is only one reason; it was not properly staked down. It has multiple stake and guy line points all around the floor and at the top. Also, of course the awning sags in the middle unless it’s staked out properly. That’s the whole point of it. And it’s not that big when packed. It’s about 30 inches long by about 12 inches in diameter. It’s a 7 foot tall tent. What do you expect? They retail for $429 right now, which is pretty good considering it’s the last tent you’d ever have to buy. Tents are like anything else, you get what you pay for…

Posted by Ken - 10/21/2009 12:04 PM

Just a rebuttle on tent size. A smaller tent is easier to keep warm and retain heat. I recommend a tent with a weather cover that reaches the ground. I have also found that a larg comforter on top of the tent before the cover goes on can make a difference of 15deg.

Posted by Steve G - 07/07/2010 06:43 PM

I have owned and used many many tents over the years and I can so without question that my Promontory tent is the best made tent I have ever owned. In over 6 years of steady use it still performs like the day I bought it. Nuff said.

Posted by Cheryl Martinez - 06/05/2013 09:03 PM

These are great camping tents! My family loves camping adventures a lot. We’re looking for something that would suit for a family of 6. I think this Paha Que Promontory is the right one for us. I really find this very interesting. Hope to grab one soon. Thanks.

-<a href=“http://www.tepuitents.com/”>TepuiTents.com</a>

Add Comment

  1. Add link by using "LinkText":http://google.com