Gear Review -- BPA-free Water Bottles

The Gear Junkie: BPA-free Water Bottles
By STEPHEN REGENOLD

BPA is in the news again. That’s short for bisphenol A, a controversial compound found in polycarbonate plastics that some studies have shown mimics the hormone estrogen and can cause medical ills in lab rats.

A new study and a continuing push by anti-BPA groups prompted several health-related organizations earlier this year to call for a moratorium on BPA, which is widely used in baby bottles.

Nalgenebottles(BPA-article)-Wt.jpg
Above: The now-discontinued BPA-containing Nalgene bottles.

For outdoorsy types, the fuss has been over water bottles, namely of the translucent type made by Nalgene Nunc International, which for years employed BPA-containing polycarbonate in its ubiquitous 16- and 32-ounce cylindrical bottles.

No longer.

Last month Nalgene (www.nalgene-outdoor.com) announced that it will cut BPA from all its bottles. In the place of the popular polycarbonate vessels, Nalgene has introduced a BPA-free line that embodies the characteristics that made its original bottles so popular: The company’s Everyday bottles are made with copolyester, a clear and colorful material that is seemingly a cousin to polycarbonate—just without the BPA.

Nalgene-nonBPA-W.jpg
Nalgene’s new BPA-free Everyday bottles.

The copolyester bottles—which come in three styles, starting at $8.25—are strong and leak-proof. Drop one from head height onto rocks and it will most likely survive, not an ounce of liquid escaping. The Everyday bottles are dishwasher safe and made to withstand temperatures from minus-40 to 212 degrees Fahrenheit.

Though Nalgene is getting all the attention this month, CamelBak (www.camelbak.com) was actually first in the copolyester game. The company announced its Better Bottle line—also polycarbonate-like vessels that do not contain BPA—a couple months back.

Camelbak-betterbottle3.jpg
CamelBak’s BPA-free Better Bottle.

Starting at $8, the CamelBak Better Bottle comes in three iterations, including 0.5-, 0.75- and 1-liter sizes. Later this month, a new Better Bottle will launch with a flip-open valve that distributes liquid via the bite-and-sip method first encountered on the company’s hydration-bladder backpacks.

Like Nalgene, Camelbak markets its water bottles to hikers and outdoors users as well as the general water-toting public. Both companies offer the copolyester bottles in multiple translucent colors, your water tinted inside and sloshing in a solid—and BPA free—container.

(Stephen Regenold writes The Gear Junkie column for eleven U.S. newspapers; see www.THEGEARJUNKIE.com for video gear reviews, a daily blog, and an archive of Regenold’s work.)

Posted by Mark - 05/10/2008 11:09 PM

And I sure hope they will offer a swap for our old Nalgene bottles.

Add Comment

  1. Add link by using "LinkText":http://google.com