Home > Outdoor

High End, Old School: Fiberglass ‘Butterstick’ Fly Rod Has Retro Appeal

Support us! GearJunkie may earn a small commission from affiliate links in this article. Learn More

Is old the new cool? In the world of fly fishing, beautiful fiberglass fly rods that give the angler a gentle presentation and an old-school feeling from the first tug right into the net are turning some to setups that would look familiar to fishermen of the ’70s.

The Butter Stick from Redington ($250) is a high-modulus fiberglass rod that just screams “old days” right down to its yellow-orange color. In a few weeks of use, I’ve found that it does a few things quite well, namely get attention and catch fish.

Redington Butter Stick

At $250, the rod is moderately priced — certainly not cheap but still half the price of some of its competition. The three-piece, four-weight model I tested breaks down to a 32” package in its included fabric rod cloth and Cordura tube, short enough to easily strap outside a backpack. It has a lifetime warranty.

I used the Butter Stick coupled with Redington’s well-matched 3/4-weight, aluminum Drift clicker reel ($99) spooled with 4-weight RIO Gold fly line on the renowned water of Colorado’s Fryingpan River.

On this mid-size river, I had no problem reaching trout tucked 20 feet away near overhanging branches, even with my mediocre casting skills. Getting them to bite, well, that was another question.

The author with a little success on the Frying Pan

During a full day, I landed a couple rainbows in the 12” to 15” range, but none of the Frying Pan’s monsters that would have really tested the rod’s butt section. I landed the trout with no problem and found the rod lively and fun in the swift-moving water.

It is available in models from two- to five-weight that range from 6’ to 8’ respectively. It is well-suited for smaller water where anglers are happy to trade casting distance for a gentle and natural presentation.

A couple weeks later, I gave the Butter Stick a try on a small lake near Denver. It was a windy day and I had trouble getting as much distance as I wanted out of the slow action rod. I kept most of my casts down short and caught a couple fish on streamers, but felt a bit discouraged about my abilities.

The author playing a small rainbow

A curious angler eyeballed the short, bright-color rod with incredulity. “Looks like it’s made for a kid,” he said. “Interesting.”

Interesting indeed. 15 minutes later I hooked into a nice Brown on the Platte River in strong current. I was thankful for the soft rod sucking up the shock and protecting the #6 tippet that held a tiny nymph.

“Score one for the kid’s rod,” I thought as I released the beautiful fish.

A nice little brown pulled from the Platte River

A week later, I was back on the same lake. More familiar with the rod and with less wind I got some decent distance — maybe 50 feet — out of my casts. And again, I caught several small rainbows that danced and fought hard and caught a stranger eyeing the rod.

He made his way over as I landed a fish and inquired about the rod.

I offered him a few casts and I could tell immediately from his beautiful loops that this older gentleman knew a thing or two about fly fishing.

“Mmmm, nice rod. Fiberglass?” he inquired. “Haven’t seen one of these in a while.”

Yes, I told him, and explained what I knew about it. I don’t think he heard a word I said, eyes glued on the rod and reel in his hands.

“Nice,” he reiterated. “Good to see someone making a nice fiberglass rod.”

I tend to agree. —Sean McCoy is the managing editor of GearJunkie.com

Subscribe Now

Sign up to receive GearJunkie content direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Now

Sign up to receive GearJunkie content direct to your inbox.