Mammut Realization 2.0 climbing shorts

Is a Built-In Harness Better? Mammut Realization Shorts 2.0 Review

This is the freest-feeling setup for sport and competition climbing.

Mammut released the original Realization Shorts in 2013, and like many climbers, I scoffed. “Is there really a need for this? Is this better in any way?” I thought.

Essentially shorts with a built-in harness, the Mammut Realization Shorts presented a super-niche product. It seemed unnecessary and gimmicky. Sport climbing harnesses are super-lightweight while remaining comfortable, and I can take them off without changing pants. I just didn’t get it.

I’ve been testing both the original Realization Shorts and the 2.0 version, launched last spring, for a full year. And, like the shorts, my thoughts have evolved. They do indeed have a place in sport or competition climbing, where they perform incredibly well.

In short: The Mammut Realization Shorts 2.0 provide a freer feeling for the gymnastic movements of sport and competition climbing. But its upsides, utility, and comfort on belay or arresting falls come with a premium price.

Mammut Realization Climbing Shorts

Mammut Realization 2.0 climbing shorts

Pulling on the Realization Shorts felt like pulling on a harness. I had to fish my legs through internal leg loops and squirm through the waist belt.

But once I zipped up the standard fly and snap closure, then tightened the dual opposing pre-threaded harness buckles, I soon forgot I was wearing an EN- and UIAA-certified rock climbing harness.

The non-adjustable leg loops and waist circumference felt on the money for my 22.5-inch thighs and 32-inch waist. And I had plenty of tails remaining on the waist adjustments.

The fabric of the shorts felt breathable, light, and stretchy, as did the drop liner. A gusseted crotch and vented lower back section round out the build. If the harness weren’t in the shorts, they would still be a top pick for sport climbing on hotter days.

Initially, I could feel both the waist belt and leg loops of the internal harness, but soon the sensation disappeared unless I intentionally thought about it.

So, are they lighter? The target audience for the Realization Shorts surely wants to know.

The verified weight of the men’s size medium Realization Shorts 2.0 is one pound. My standard warm-weather combination of an Edelrid Ace harness and Mammut Crashiano shorts comes in at the same weight. So, at least for me, there are no weight savings.

Review: Mammut Realization Shorts 2.0

Mammut Realization 2.0 climbing shorts harness

Before climbing in the Realization Shorts 2.0, I never noticed my harness hindering me while on the route. I may have noted its shortcomings while hanging or during a lead fall, but with the higher-end harnesses I’m fortunate to test, these instances were rare.

But wearing the Realization Shorts 2.0 changed that. Going climbing on back-to-back days, once in the shorts and once with a standard harness, revealed the free feeling of Mammut’s hybrid product. I felt unencumbered — like I was climbing in shorts alone.

Wide stems, high-stepping, extreme twisting, and other body contortions felt unhindered. My shorts didn’t have to slide under leg loops, and I didn’t feel the waist belt twisting around me as much. But honestly, I wouldn’t have noticed this without back-to-back comparison.

Where I saw the most performance improvement was when the Realization Shorts were loaded in a fall, while hanging, or while belaying. The pressure transferred through the surface area of the waist belt, and the leg loops felt more spread out. The amount of force distributed to the shorts had to be relatively small, with the sensation more significant than the reality, but it was definitely there.

As for the rack, the two gear loops were always where I expected them to be for sport climbing. They had a satisfying stiffness that kept me from noticing them while removing or replacing quickdraws.

On the apparel side, I wore the Realization Shorts 2.0 for 4 days of hot, humid cragging and didn’t notice any odors. But I did see soiling caused by chalk mixing with sweat.

Washing them wasn’t anything out of the ordinary, though I wonder how many washings the Realization Shorts 2.0 can handle over their usable life. If you’re the type of person that avoids washing harnesses and ropes for fear of potential damage, this would be a concern.

What’s Different

There were a few peculiarities associated with climbing in the Realization Shorts 2.0. First, they’re curiously devoid of any way to directly attach a chalk bag, preventing them from having the total package.

But that wasn’t all. Tying into a single point caused an initial mental hiccup. I had to remind myself that the tie-in point is fully rated and that it wasn’t any different than trusting a standard belay loop to catch falls.

This mental blip only occurred while tying in for the first time each day. The same thing happened while putting my partner on belay for the first time each day — the small belay loop only goes through the single tie-in point.

Mammut Realization 2.0 climbing shorts

The Realization Shorts 2.0 also generated inquiring looks, both while climbing and while on belay duty. People would question what I was doing, and my standard “they are shorts with a built-in harness” reply universally elicited even more curiosity.

Finally, there is simply a lack of pockets. This omission wasn’t an issue while cragging, only when going to and coming from climbing. And having no pockets was a slight annoyance when hitting the pub afterward.

Conclusions

The Mammut Realization Shorts 2.0 offer a niche product for the sport and indoor climber who desires the freest-feeling setup possible while climbing — and who has $220 to spend on shorts. As a lightweight sport climbing harness, the shorts have a few minor differences, but they provide a touch more comfort during falls, while hang-dogging, and while on belay.

Although it may be attractive to the sport or competition climber looking for every potential advantage, I see the hybridization being more useful in adventure climbing. Big-wall climbing, alpine climbing, and mountaineering also seem like they would benefit from the harness-in-pants design.

Seiji Ishii
By

Seiji Ishii has enjoyed a lifetime of outdoor adventure and sports, from participant and competitor to coach and trainer, and finally as an editorial contributor. His interests have spanned cycling, climbing, motorcycling, backpacking, trail running, and the training involved for all of it. He has also designed outdoor and off-road motorcycling gear. He lives in a wildlife refuge in Wimberley, Texas, with his daughter, itinerant dirt bags, a dog, and a cat. Read more of his musings at seijisays.com.

Topics: ,

Tags: