Hunting arrows are not a one-size-fits-all piece of gear. Your hunting style, bow setup, and even the species you are hunting need to be taken into consideration when choosing an arrow.
The more time I spend behind the bow, the more I have realized how important hunting arrow selection is. With that said, it’s a rabbit hole and a quite daunting one at that. This can leave one’s head spinning in all sorts of wrong directions. We’re here to set that right.
Down below, you’re going to find our take on what arrows need to be on your radar for the upcoming 2024 fall hunting season.
These are my favorite arrows for a range of applications and budgets. This selection is evolving so be sure to check for updates, as new arrows will be added as they’re tested. At the end of our list, be sure to check out the comparison chart and buyer’s guide.
Editor’s note: For our February 20, 2024 update, we’ve freshened up our selection for spring, adding reviews of the Easton x10 Parallel Pro, the Altra Centrum Premier .166, and the Easton 6.5 Hunter Classic.
The Best Hunting Arrows of 2024
- Best Overall Hunting Arrow: VAP TKO
- Best Budget Hunting Arrow: Gold Tip Hunter
- Best Arrow for Deer Hunting: Easton x10 Parallel Pro
- Best Arrow for Elk Hunting: Day Six HD
- Best Traditional Arrow: Black Eagle Instinct Traditional
- Material: 100% carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.166”
- Spines: 300, 350, 400
Pros
- Great penetration
- Pulls easy out of targets
- Micro diameter bucks wind well
Cons
- Stock inserts aren’t the greatest
- Material: Carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.246”
- Spines: 300, 340, 400, 500
Pros
- Affordable
- Readily available
- Performs with the best of them
Cons
- Not offered in a micro diameter version
- Material: Carbon with 7075 alloy core
- Outside diameter: 0.236”(300 spine)
- Spines: 250, 300, 350, 380, 420, 470, 520, 570, 610, 660, 710, 810, 880, 1000, and 1150
Pros
- Extremely tight tolerances = Better accuracy
- More lightweight
- Wide range of spines available
Cons
- Very expensive
- Material: Carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.253”(300 spine)
- Spines: 250, 275, 300, 350, 400, 500
Pros
- Wide range of available spines
- Incredibly durable
- Made in the USA
Cons
- Can’t buy in a shop (direct to consumer)
- Material: Carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.248” (350 spine)
- Spines: 350, 400, 500, 600
Pros
- Wide range of spines
- Keeps the old-timey look of wooden arrows
- Only arrow of its kind
Cons
- Doesn’t come in the popular 300 spine
- Material: High modulus carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.166”
- Spines: 250, 300, 350, 400
Pros
- Wide range of spines
- Excellent component system: ARCOS Insert/Outsert System
- No spine technology; no true stiff side of the arrow means more consistent flight at a lower barrier of entry
Cons
- High GPI and no option for lower. If you want a lighter arrow, this may not be for you.
- Material: Carbon (Acu-Carbon Uniform Spine Process)
- Outside diameter: 0.300”(300 spine)
- Spines: 250, 300, 340, 400, 500
Pros
- Affordable
- Wide range of spines
- No need for spine alignment
Cons
- Not the most durable
- Material: 100% high mod carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.209-0.256”
- Spines: 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 500, 600, 700, 800, and 900
Pros
- Very wide range of spines available
- Light arrow for flatter trajectory
- Allows for more point weight upfront
Cons
- High mod carbon tends to be more brittle
- Material: 30-ton carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.166”
- Spines: 300, 350, 400
Pros
- Durable
- Tri-spine/Red zone technology for ⅓ less oscillation in arrow flight
- Laser checked for straightness, not averaged
Cons
- Only offered in 3 different spines
- Material: Carbon core wrapped in 7075 aluminum
- Outside diameter: 0.240”(340 spine)
- Spines: 250, 300, 340, 400
Pros
- Unique design
- A long list of proven experience
- Heavy hitter
Cons
- Can bend and render the arrow useless
- Material: 100% carbon
- Outside diameter: 0.296” (340 spine)
- Spines: 300, 340, 400, 500, 600
Pros
- Caters to speed
- Flatter trajectory
- Wide range of spines
Cons
- Lighter weight may decrease durability
- Material: Carbon and stainless steel
- Outside diameter: 0.204”
- Spines: 250, 300, 350, 400
Pros
- Unique design
- Great momentum
- Wide range of spines offered
Cons
- Might be a little heavy for some folks
Hunting Arrow Comparison Chart
Arrow | Price | Material | Outside Diameter | Spines |
---|---|---|---|---|
Victory VAP TKO Elite Arrows | $180 | 100% carbon | 0.166” | 300, 350, 400 |
Gold Tip Hunter | $54 | Carbon | 0.246” | 300, 340, 400, 500 |
Easton x10 Parallel Pro | $250 | Carbon with 7075 alloy core | 0.236” (300 spine) | 250, 300, 350, 380, 420, 470, 520, 570, 610, 660, 710, 810, 880, 1000, and 1150 |
Day Six HD | $234 | Carbon | 0.253” (300 spine) | 50, 275, 300, 350, 400, 500 |
Black Eagle Instinct Traditional | $80 | Carbon | 0.248” (350 spine) | 350, 400, 500, 600 |
Altra Centrum Premier .166 | $109 | High modulus carbon | 0.166” | 250, 300, 350, 400 |
Easton 6.5 Hunter Classic | $120 | Carbon (Acu-Carbon Uniform Spine Process) | 0.300” (300 spine) | 250, 300, 340, 400, 500 |
Black Eagle X-Impact | $195 | 100% high mod carbon | 0.209-0.256” | 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 500, 600, 700, 800, and 900 |
Carbon Express Maxima Triad | $300 | 30-ton carbon | 0.166” | 300, 350, 400 |
Easton FMJ 4mm | $200 | Carbon core wrapped in 7075 aluminum | 0.240” (340 spine) | 250, 300, 340, 400 |
Gold Tip Velocity Pro | $169 | 100% carbon | 0.296” (340 spine) | 300, 340, 400, 500, 600 |
Victory RIP SS Elite Arrows | $130 | Carbon and stainless steel | 0.204” | 250, 300, 350, 400 |

Why You Should Trust Us

Buying Guide: How to Choose a Hunting Arrow

Heavy Hunting Arrows Equal Momentum
The Downside of Heavy Arrows

Light Hunting Arrows Equal Speed

Cons of Lightweight Hunting Arrows

Middle of the Road: A Hunting Arrow That’s Just Right
Arrow Flight Is Everything

Frequently Asked Questions
The arrow that is best for hunting is the one that you can be the most accurate with. With that said, we stand behind our top pick: the Victory VAP TKO. Check out our guides about broadheads and archery release aids to round out your kit. Both contain some great info to help you choose the right setup for what you’re hunting.
Arrow speeds between 250 fps and 300 fps are ideal for deer-sized game and larger animals.
The minimum arrow weight recommended for a 70# draw is 350 grains. So, any arrow 350 grains and above — with the proper length and spine — will do well with a 70# draw weight bow.
You can refer to our Buyer’s Guide above for a more in-depth look at this, but heavier arrows are going to, by design, retain more momentum after impact than a lighter arrow. On the flip side, heavier arrows will have a steeper arrow trajectory than lighter arrows, thus lacking forgiveness when it comes to yardage estimation.
In general, your arrow should be no shorter than the middle of your riser at full draw. Keep in mind though that with certain broadheads, this may not be possible. Larger profile broadheads might run into the riser on shorter arrows.

The Best Broadheads for Hunting in 2024
Finding the right broadhead for you can be the difference between filling a tag and not. Here’s our list of game-dropping broadheads for 2024.

The Best Archery Release Aids for Bowhunting of 2024
Archery release aids are an indispensable tool for all but the most traditional bowhunters. Here we lay out the best releases of 2024.